30 August 2021

A Birthday Playlist

Those close to me know that Janamasthmi is special to me. This blog has seen multiple posts on the occasion of Janamasthmi. In 2011, I even described it as the best day of my life. In 2015, I wrote about various writings on Bhagwan Shri Krishna.

So what do I have to offer in 2021? This year, I have curated a playlist of my favourite Shri Krishna bhajans. I cannot sing for you, but I can certainly share good compositions with you. I wish I could sing beautifully for God. I am somewhat lethargically pretending to learn. Maybe one day I will manage to sing.

Until then, in no particular order:

  1. Madhurashtakam by Dr. Subhadra Desai sung in a Raga Maala i.e.: the Raga changes after 2 verses. The rendering of the fifth and sixth verses in Raga Yaman are my favourite.
  2. Jamuna Kinaare Mora Gaon by Pt. Mukul Shivputra. I love the part when it says - मली मली के स्नान कराओं
  3. Kaun Gali Gayo Shyam by Dr. Prabha Atre. I have heard this countless times and even today when I hear it, I can intensely feel the longing for Krishna.
  4. Krishna Nee Begane by Aruna Sairam. This bhajan is in Kannada. This rendition was apparently sung live at India Gate. It have heard it so many times that I have started to pick up the Kannada!
  5. Mharo Pranam by Kishori Amonkar. This is a classic. Meera's love for Krishna is unparalleled. We shy away from making the smallest sacrifices for God, and here was Meera, who sacrificed everything!
  6. Govind Damodar Madhaveti by Pt. Jasraj. Sometimes when I want to feel enthused with energy, I play this on my way to work. It's so powerful!
  7. Aage Krishna Paachhe Krishna by Mokshi Sethi. Everywhere I see, there is Krishna - what an amazing feeling. Close your eyes and imagine there is Krishna in front of you and see how your heart reacts. Now, think if He was everywhere you looked.
  8. Om Namo Bhagavate by Pt. Sanjeev Abhyankar. I have had the good fortune of hearing this live. It was surreal - almost trance like. The rare times when you are totally lost in the music.
  9. Bhaja Govindam by M.S. Subbulakshmi. I am true Vedanti and so this has to feature here. You have seen Bhaja Govindam references innumerable times. Bhaja Govindam! Bhaja Govindam!
  10. Mana Mohan Shyam by Dr. Ashwini Bhide Deshpande. I heard this only last week and it instantly became special to me. Ashwini ji has such a unique way of singing.
  11. Manmohan Man Mein Ho Tumhi by Mohd. Rafi and Suman Kalyanpur. I came across this when listening to the radio. Sometimes radio really surprises you. What an incredible find!
I hope you like these. Here is the link to the entire playlist.

May Krishna always be with you.

22 August 2021

The Beloved Self

The other morning, while commuting to work, I heard the song Laila Laila from the movie Andhadhun. The words that caught my attention were मेरे दिल के, दिल के, दिल के भी दिल मे है तु. Translated it is - You are in the heart of the heart of the heart of my heart. The words are spoken by a lover to his beloved.

These words reminded me of a beautiful imagery that is described in the Kathopanishad (Verse 12, Valli 1, Chapter 2):

अङ्गुष्ठमात्रः पुरुषो मध्य आत्मनि तिष्ठति ।

ईशानं भूतभव्यस्य न ततो विजुगुप्सते । एतद्वै तत् ॥ १२॥

12. The Being (Purusha), of the size of the thumb, resides in the body. 
Knowing Him as the ruler of the past and the future, one does not want, by virtue of that knowledge, to save the Self. This indeed is that.

[Translation by Swami Gambhirananda]

The commentary by Bhagwan Adi Shankaracharya, as explained in the texts and discourses of spiritual masters, on the above verse describes the imagery. The Self (i.e.: God) is declared to be residing in the middle of the (gross) body. This 'middle' is found roughly 10 fingers above the navel (i.e.: close to the biological heart). The heart area is in the shape of a lotus (हृदयपुण्डरीकं). The size of the heart space is equivalent to first joint of the right hand thumb (अङ्गुष्ठमात्रः). Within the lotus heart, there is an opening (छिद्र). In that opening, lies the internal organ or seat of thinking and feeling (अन्तःकरण - unfortunately, there is no adequate word for this in English and the word 'internal organ' is used in this post. In Swami Harshananda's A Dictionary of Advaita Vedanta, it is defined as - it is the internal organ or instrument by which we experience thinking, feeling and willing and are able to remember things. Though sometimes loosely called as mind (manas) or intellect (buddhi), it is more basic, of which these two are only aspects. Citta (mind-stuff) and ahankara (egoism) are two more aspects, making four in all). The Self is said to reside in this internal organ and Its presence is experienced when the internal organ is quiet/at peace (शांत).

The verse describes a method of mediation with the heart space as the focus area. There are multiple layers in the mediation (i.e.: the gross body to the heart to the opening to the internal organ), just like the aforementioned song. In both the situations, the layers are described to indicate the idea of the innermost i.e.: the beloved and the Self are the innermost.

But, why the heart? Why not the legs, hands, liver, eyes etc.? Biologically, the heart is the foremost organ and its cessation is closely linked with death. Quite apart from that, it is also the seat of emotions (as this is where the mind, an aspect of the internal organ, is said to reside). This is not just a philosophical idea, but a lived experience, as this is where the pain is actually felt. The heart space is also the place where the presence of the Self is more easily experienced. Try it. Try focussing on the heart space and you will feel a sense of peace and calm. In fact, there is an entire movement called Heartfulness.

Thus, the importance of the heart in love.

[Some of you may remember the reference to the heart cavity in an earlier post, where also a verse from the Kathopanishad was mentioned. As you would have guessed, I am currently listening to the discourses on the Kathopanishad from Swamiji. The above explanation of the verse is also drawn from Swami Maheshananda Giri ji's commentary on the Kathopanishad. 

The Upanishads are replete with references about the Self residing in the heart. Perhaps, one day, I will compile them all. Who knows - maybe that's the book I will finally end up writing. For the moment, I will only say that a similar reference also appears in the Svetasvatara Upanishad- see Verse 13, Chapter 3.]

I was also reminded of another Shloka from Kenopanishad (Verse 2, Part 1). Over there, Brahman is described as the ear of the ear, the eye of the eye etc.:

श्रोत्रस्य श्रोत्रं मनसो मनो यद्
    वाचो ह वाचं स उ प्राणस्य प्राणः ।
चक्षुषश्चक्षुरतिमुच्य धीराः
    प्रेत्यास्माल्लोकादमृता भवन्ति ॥ २॥

2. Since He is the Ear of the ear, the Mind of the mind, the Speech of the speech, the Life of the life, and the Eye of the eye, therefore the intelligent men after giving up (the self identification with the senses) and renouncing this world, become immortal.

[Translation by Swami Gambhirananda]

The song mentioned above also employs similar phraseology, where the residence of the beloved is described in the heart of the heart etc. In the above verse, the Ultimate is described as that which enables the ear to hear, the mind to feel, the speech to speak, the eye to see etc. In that sense, the Self is the director of everything. In the words of Swami Gambhirananda - "There does exist something which is known to the intellect of men of realisation, which dwells in the inmost recess of all, which is changeless, undecaying, immortal, fearless, and unborn, and which the Ear etc. of even the ear etc., i.e.: the source of their capacity to act." Thus, once again, the addition of degrees is aimed at conveying the idea of the innermost.

I am reminded of two Bhajans that also mention the indwelling Self. The first one is a Kabir Bhajan - Haman Hai Ishq-e-Mastana, Haman Ko Hoshiyari Kya. The Bhajan has been beautifully sung by Pt. Madhup Mudgal ji. Do listen - it also has line by line translation. The following verses are relevant to our discussion here:

जो बिछुड़े हैं पियारे से,
भटकते दर-ब-दर फिरते
हमारा यार है हम में
हमन को  इंतजारी क्या?
Those who are separated from their Beloved, wander from place to place
My Friend is in me, why do I need to wait for Him?

The Bhajan emphatically states that God is the Beloved. It also reiterates that God/Brahman is most conveniently experienced within us. The Beloved that we seek can never be separated from us.

As I write this, I am also reminded of another Kabir Bhajan (which was originally not contemplated in this post)- Ik dui hoy unhain samujhavaun. This one has been sung by Ashwini Bhide Deshpande ji. The feelings invoked in this Bhajan are quite different from the previous one. While the former conveys feelings of love, this one conveys feelings of dispassion (वैराग्य) and the utter blindness of the world. The relevant verse is:

घर की वस्तु नजर नहि आवत,
दियना बारि के ढूँढत अन्धा
The Thing inside the house, one does not see
Lights a lamp and searches blindly outside

The inside and outside here are with reference to the gross body (described as the house). It describes our endless search for things in the external and material world, when in fact, the most precious Thing is inside us. A word of caution regarding inside/outside. By stating that God is inside, it does not imply that He is not outside. He is more conveniently experienced inside. Also, it should be borne in mind that the more subtle an object, the more vast it is. The more gross an object, the more limited it is. Thus, despite It being the innermost and subtler than the subtlest, it is by far the most vast.

The other Bhajan, which my wife beautifully sang last year during the lockdown, is Bheetar hai sakha, tera sakha. The chorus of the Bhajan is:

भीतर है सखा तेरा सखा मन लगा के देख ,
अंतःकरण में ज्ञान की ज्योति जला के देख |
Your Friend is within, focus your mind and see (just try),
Light the lamp of knowledge in the internal organ and see (just try).

The reference to the Friend here is to the Self/Brahman/God. The message of the Bhajan is - just try and focus your mind and you shall experience It. Once again, It is within. Look within.

The reference to the Lord residing within us also comes in the last verse of the Bhaja Govindam. In this verse, Bhagwan Adi Shankaracharya blesses all his students, that they may be able to discipline their sense organs and mind and thus become liberated:

गुरुचरणाम्बुजनिर्भरभक्तः
संसारादचिराद्भव मुक्तः ।
सेन्द्रियमानसनियमादेवं
द्रक्ष्यसि निजहृदयस्थं देवम् ॥ ३१॥ 

31. O Devotee of the lotus feet of the teacher! May you become liberated soon from the samsara through the discipline of the sense organs and the mind. You will come to experience (behold) the Lord that dwells in your own heart.

[Translation by Swami Chinmayananda]

In the end, I would like to mention one last verse from the Guru Geeta that is found in the Skanda Purana. In this verse, Lord Mahadeva (Shiva) addresses Goddess Parvati and says to her:

मम रूपासि देवि त्वमतस्तत्कथयामि ते ।
लोकोपकारकः प्रश्नो न केनापि कृतः पुरा ॥ 

O Parvati, You are My very Self. For your satisfaction I shall tell you (what you have requested Me to say). Your question was put with a view to doing good to all; no one else has put it to Me so far.

[Translation by Prof. J. N. Sharma]

The above verse brings us back to Laila Laila. In the song, the lover says that his beloved resides in the heart of the heart etc. We saw above that the Self also lies within the heart of the heart etc. and is the innermost. Thus, the beloved and the Self occupy the same lotus heart space. The Bhajans make it clear that the Self is the Friend and the Beloved. And, finally, here is Lord Mahadeva addressing Goddess Parvati as His very Self.  Thus, stand united the beloved and the Self.

May you and your beloved always be with the Self.

Hari Om Tat Sat

[Painting by Mokshi Sethi]

15 August 2021

Freedom

Today is Independence Day and so thoughts naturally gravitate towards the idea of freedom. In the past couple of years, and more so after becoming a lawyer, I realized the ease with which our freedoms can be taken away. Demonetization saw a restriction on our freedom to spend our own money. The continued use of Section 66A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 in India shows that the powers that be, can even use illegal provisions to curtail free speech. The Covid-19 pandemic saw the most drastic restrictions, especially on our ability to work and to move freely (albeit legitimately). I am not suggesting that all restrictions by the State are unreasonable, arbitrary, and not in accordance with law. These are matters for the courts to decide. I want to point out that independence from a foreign imperialist power does not necessarily imply that we are now absolutely free. The State (and the Corporates) exercise much control over us, sometimes justified, sometimes not, sometimes we realise and sometimes we don’t. In fact, one could even argue that States today exercise much greater control over their people vis-à-vis 100 years ago. It is all very Animal Farm-ish.

Now before I start sounding like an anarchist, let me clarify that I am not a votary of jungle rule. I believe that for there to be order in the world, restrictions are necessary. The nature of these restrictions varies in cultures, communities, and regions. Adherence to these restrictions is ensured by creating a punishment for their non-compliance. The restrictions are also characterized as duties. The question – “Why must I do my duty?” is answered in terms of morality and/or religion and/or ‘you ought to’ (or their variations), depending on the culture, community and/or region. At the cost of sounding cliché, the jungle freedoms are compromised/ceded in favour of restrictions to ensure order in society. Therefore, in society (whether governed by a foreign imperialist power or not), there will never be full freedom.

The natural question from the above is – “Can we ever be free?”. Death is not freedom. Those who believe that body is all that there is, for them, after death, nothing exists. In non-existence, there is no concept of bondage or freedom. For those who believe in a soul or some sort of other world, there is again no freedom, for you simply transmigrate into another world or time; to be bound by the rules of that world or time. 

Vedanta, on the other hand, gives the promise of freedom from all bondage (liberation or Moksha). Vedanta promises freedom from fruits of action (कर्मबंध) and repeated births and deaths (जन्मबंध). The promise is also not made for a future time or place, but that liberation can be found here and now, in this birth itself. All that needs to be done is the removal of the error that I am this combination of body, mind, and intellect. Once this error is removed, the Truth will shine forth i.e.: I am Brahman, I am All. In that state, there is endless bliss. That liberation is true liberation.

I would like to end with one of my favourite verses from the Bhaja Govindam:

पुनरपि जननं पुनरपि मरणं
पुनरपि जननीजठरे शयनम् ।
इह संसारे बहुदुस्तारे
कृपयाऽपारे पाहि मुरारे ॥ २१॥

Again birth, again death and again lying in mother’s womb – this samsara process is very hard to cross over. Save me, Murari (O destroyer of Mura) through Thy infinite kindness.

[Translation by Swami Chinmayanada]

On this Independence Day, I am going to begin an online Vedanta course. I hope that today you too would take one step towards the ultimate independence.

Hari Om Tat Sat

[2015, Law Faculty, Delhi University, I-day celebrations]